There are new competitors who do great on the GenAI benchmarks without using the top of the line Nvidia chips, indeed not many chips of any sort.
https://www.analyticsvidhya.com/blog/2025/01/deepseek-r1-vs-openai-o1/
Past Week | Past Month | Past Year | This Season | All Time | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Forecasts | 1 | 4 | 695 | 22 | 3740 |
Comments | 1 | 5 | 294 | 27 | 2093 |
Questions Forecasted | 1 | 2 | 68 | 8 | 213 |
Upvotes on Comments By This User | 1 | 3 | 304 | 19 | 1726 |
Definitions |
There are new competitors who do great on the GenAI benchmarks without using the top of the line Nvidia chips, indeed not many chips of any sort.
https://www.analyticsvidhya.com/blog/2025/01/deepseek-r1-vs-openai-o1/
These cheap newcomers look great, but are they? Indeed, even the biggest users of Nvidia chips have questionable performances.
Several aspects here:
(1) So what if they only look great by being designed, thanks to their training data, to do well on the benchmark tests? Consumers only care about results. Source: https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2025/03/chatbots-benchmark-tests/681929/
(2) If the cheap new GenAIs are making consumers happy, who cares what is under the hood?
(3) What if the use case collapses for users of high end GenAIs?
(4) Chaos among the owners of the high end GenAIs and their beloved Donald Trump could easily crash the US and even world economy. Elon Musk, looking at you!
(5) Yet, the economy and markets for Nvidia chips could remain elevated and ever surge before the end of May.
(6) If markets were rational, how come our Pro Forecasters aren't all billionaires? Are there any billionaire Pro Focasters?
Still no sign of preparations for a test at https://www.38north.org/
Might Trump's apparent abandonment of Ukraine entice NK to try to seize South Korea? Might that create a need for testing a small tactical nuclear weapon? In that case, NK might build a new test site to supercede the fatally damaged Mt. Mantap. Could they do that within six months? Alternatively, NK might decide to heck with the likely resulting radioactive pollution and set off one inside the new tunnel bored (how far?) into the rubble pile of Mt. Mantap.
Sometimes, less is more. Is that time arriving in the world of users of NVIDIA chips?
Dateline 2-28-2025 S1 is based on a small, off-the-shelf AI model from Alibaba-owned Chinese AI lab Qwen, which is available to download for free. To train s1, the researchers created a dataset of just 1,000 carefully curated questions, paired with answers to those questions, as well as the “thinking” process behind each answer from Google’s Gemini 2.0 Flash Thinking Experimental.
After training s1, which took less than 30 minutes using 16 Nvidia H100 GPUs, s1 achieved strong performance on certain AI benchmarks, according to the researchers. Niklas Muennighoff, a Stanford researcher who worked on the project, told TechCrunch he could rent the necessary compute today for about $20.
The researchers used a nifty trick to get s1 to double-check its work and extend its “thinking” time: They told it to wait. Adding the word “wait” during s1’s reasoning helped the model arrive at slightly more accurate answers, per the paper.
Too low? The less is more class of AIs such as DeepSeek and S1 do well on well-known benchmarks. But how good are they at the tasks most users of the foundation GenAI require?
Too high? How long can NVIDIA stock investors remain bullish in the face of Elon Musk and President Trump following the break it down and rebuild it strategy that now seems to be working for X (formerly Twitter)? The spigot of the continuing massive investments in LLM-based GenAIs could suddenly turn off.
Recent rollout of Blackwell could slow chip deliveries and introduces more uncertainty.
Dateline 2-17-2025 Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang said on the company’s last earnings call in November that Blackwell production “is in full steam.” But many analysts don’t expect those Blackwell shipments to hit high volume until the second half of the new fiscal year, which could mean a disappointing forecast from Nvidia for its April-ending quarter.
Source: https://www.wsj.com/finance/stocks/deepseek-did-nvidia-a-favor-508c7e27
Too low? US GenAI customers apparently haven't (yet!) been deeply affected by Chinese GenAI companies.
Too high? China's GenAI industry may have more surprises in store.
China is far too vulnerable to economic retaliation. Given its currently shaky economy, and by comparison with how easily mass protests developed against its Covid restrictions, I doubt that its leaders would dare to even just blockade Taiwan within six months.
Dateline 1-27-2025 China’s economy has slowed and faces a multitude of challenges: a real estate crash, banks burdened with bad loans, youth unemployment and underemployment, highly indebted local governments, and a population both aging and declining. On top of that, foreign investment is dropping. Indeed, not just falling but reversing.
Source: https://www.cato.org/commentary/chinas-faltering-economy-investment-beijings-challenge-home#
Comparison class: Putin should have known how much harm his full-scale invasion of Ukraine would do to the economy of his Russian Federation. Yet so far there are hardly any signs of popular unrest.
See also, Cromwell's Rule of Probabilities. Summary: there is a non-zero change that the Moon is made of Green Cheese.
See "Rapid in silico directed evolution by a protein language model with EVOLVEpro," https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adr6006 Dated
Editor’s summary
Altering protein function or stability through mutations is a powerful tool for engineering, but it is experimentally demanding to explore even a small fraction of potential mutations. Jiang et al. developed a computational approach called EVOLVEpro that uses recently developed protein language models within the framework of a top-layer regression model. A small number of experimental observations can guide protein evolution toward the desired functional outcomes and avoid stable, but nonfunctional, deadends. The authors demonstrate the capabilities of the method for evolving desired functions in six different example cases relevant to current molecular biology challenges, including evolving a miniature CRISPR nuclease, optimized antibodies, and an improved T7 RNA polymerase. —Michael A. Funk
This question isn't just about "can it be done." It also requires that the FDA must allow it. I have far more confidence that some other nation would be allowing in silico tests to be escalated to human subjects. @DimaKlenchin you vastly more expertise on this than me. What is your take? It's in the Jan. 24, 2025 issue.
Still no sign of preparations for a nuclear test. Source: https://www.38north.org
Murphy's Law.
Why do you think you're right?
The gap between Apple and NVIDIA today is $407B. This compares with @geoffodlum reporting $239B March 16 here https://www.randforecastinginitiative.org/comments/161803
Why might you be wrong?
I'm tempted to game this one by going to zero, but Murphy's Law is deterring me.
Part of the decline could be attributed by news of GenAI competitors seeking alternatives to NVIDIA:
https://research.aimultiple.com/ai-chip-makers/
https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/investing/nvidia-competitors